Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

Help Massive Plant Melt

  • Thread starter Thread starter filmpunk
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
Joined
May 27, 2025
Messages
49
Reaction score
81
Location
San Antonio, Texas
So I've been trying to recover this farm tank after having been neglected for a couple months after my injury. I had lost some plants which I could understand for obvious reasons. However it seems as though since I've resumed maintenance Its had a major negative impact on the tank. Since resuming water changes & Co2 injection I've had a major issue with plant melt: hygophila araguaia which had been decent has been completely wiped out, buces are shedding leaves at an alarming rate, lagenandra meeboldii green which was easily the largest plant in the tank is a shaddow of its former self and continues to decline, I attributed this melt as likely being a combination of factors:

A.) Aquarium had stopped being dosed with fertilizers and plants had become weak
B.) Co2 bottle had run dry and now suddenly Co2 injection had resumed.
C.) Lack of water changes caused the plants to use up or at least deplete available minerals which were not being replaced with each water change.

My theory was these factors combined with resuming maintenance, co2 injection, etc were drastic enough to cause a significant change in water parameters from what the plants had adapated to.

I had ordered some new plants to replace some that were lost, mostly tissue culture which is what I've had pretty great success with. However now many of these new plants are pretty much also instantly melting. Pogostemon helferi specifically, but also some some swords (echinodorus red diamond) being the hardest hit, but ozelot also struggling.

Nutrient dosing targets:
30mL dose provides
Macros
NO3 via KNO3 - 20ppm
P via KH2PO4 - 1.5ppm
K via KNO3+KH2PO4+K2SO4 - 20 ppm

Micros
Fe via CSM+B - 0.5ppm
Ferts are dosed 10mL at at the time 3x/ week on alternating days.

I use RO water and APT Sky+ to remineralize using the calculator on 2 Hr Aquarist website, and according to the calculator my dosages should put me around 7GH and 1.9KH.
I was going to check water hardness last night but my solution is expired so I need to pick up some more today just for verification purposes. While the tank SHOULD be somewhere in the neighborhood provided by the APT SKY+ when I tested KH (not expired) it tested at 4dKH :unsure:. Lights are on for 7 hours per day, Co2 Injection begins 1.5 hours before lights on and shuts off 1 hour before lights off. pH is 7.4 and pH drop is approximately 1.2 using an apera pH meter (Tank has no inhabitants other than plants). Drop checker Green. TDS 225. I will add that the tank does start seeing some pretty decent ambient light from the room for several hours before lights on, so I'm not sure if this makes a difference. I'm skeptical because everything had been doing fine until the maintenance fell off during my injury, and the decline really accelerated once the water changes/ Co2 injection resumed. Its not everything in the tank, there are plants that bouncing back, the echinodorus Aflame, blyxa japonica, and crypt lucens all seem to be either doing fine or recovering with new growth. I'm at a complete loss, and by no means an expert, I would love any input, ideas, insights that you all could offer. TIA.
 
Update: finally seeing new growth on my lagenandra meeboldii green, noticed 2 new leaves starting to develop yesterday so maybe things are beginning to turn around 🤞. Also hopeful that the melt I've been experiencing on the new plants and tissue cultures is merely the result of adapting to the new environment. Buces are looking like hell but they are slow growers and I'm gonna hold faith that they'll recover.
 
Pogostemon helferi specifically, but also some some swords (echinodorus red diamond) being the hardest hit, but ozelot also struggling

How is your flow around this tank?

I'd be interested to hear other people's experience trying to grow helferi in soft-ish water. My pogo helferi really hates my 3° dKH . Initial fat healthy plants melted completely away after a similar CO2 incident, new growth is glacially slow and it doesn't want to root 🙄🙄

May be contributing to the slow recovery of your swords too?
 
When I initially tried growing helferi I was attempting to use a 50/50 mix of ro & incredibly hard tap water and most of it began melting away and I assumed it was the hard water so I switched to ro and the helferi that remained actually recovered in the softer water 🤷‍♂️ .Flow around tank is pretty good, maybe even a bit strong, most plants have a decent sway without substrate being washed around. Last 2 water changes I've actually reduced the amount of apt sky+ I've been adding. According to the calculator my kh should have been about 1.9 but I've reduced it to 1.8 in an effort to lower my pH closer 7.0
 
How is your flow around this tank?

I'd be interested to hear other people's experience trying to grow helferi in soft-ish water. My pogo helferi really hates my 3° dKH. Initial fat healthy plants melted completely away after a similar CO2 incident, new growth is glacially slow and it doesn't want to root 🙄🙄

May be contributing to the slow recovery of your swords too?
Regular helferi always eventually melts away in my 0.5dkh tank. It will grow for a short period, then begin to melt from the roots up.
Helferi red, for some reason survives, although it grows quite slowly.
 

Top 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top