Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

Social Feed

PeerUnk
Supporting
Last reply · posted in Journals
Hi all, loving the journal threads the most, so maybe it’s nice to share my own stuff. It’s way out of my comfort zone, but hey, learning is all about doing stuff outside it, so here it goes!

People like pictures, so this is my display tank this morning.
1741858814195.jpeg
1741858785049.jpeg
Some specs:
  • non CO2 injected, using two Eheim 400L/h air pumps to keep the CO2 out of the depletion zone.
  • non heated: 17-18 *C during the winter and up to about 26 in the summer.
  • Livestock? 15x Tanichthys micagemmae and as janitors 200-300 Neocaridinas and countless snails.
  • Using K1 micro as biological filtration in an in-tank DYI PVC circulation device.
  • For flow: 3 flow / wave makers, total roughly 7500 L/h. And a big DYI muffled Czech air lift.
  • Currently it's somewhere between 1-2 dKH, CO2 fluctuating daily between 1.2 and 2 ppm.
  • water changes? every 1 or 2 weeks, 15% (= 75 liters) with RO and 5 liter tap water. The added water gets targeted nutrients: N=2.2 K=4.2 P=0.5 Ca=8.7 Mg=3.9 S=10 Cl=1.5 Na=1. Conductivity is 180 uS/cm (TDS would be 90-120 mg/L?).
  • daily added tracemix 0.004 Fe as proxy.
  • 2 professional grow tubes (LED 3000K, both 24 watts / 2600 lumen) and a Daytime Onex Color 40 watt, 6400 lumen. This would mean roughly 20-25 lumen/L, or medium light according to Tropica.
  • Substrate-wise: 80% inert black gravel (quartz?) 2-4 mm and 20% ADA Amazonia V2 for buffer capacity and earth worm casting as substrate supplement.
Commenting my own tank:
  • The water is still a bit hazy/ white cloudy. It's like that for a year now. I didn't use any mechanical filtration for like for 3 years, so this week I did a 24 hour test run with a pre filtered 5 micron cartridge filter, which helped tremendously. My assumption such a low stocked tank might not need it, so not sure to to progress with it.
  • I might introduce a new fish species, I like Dario, which likes the temps and are no food competitors for the T. micagemmae. Not sure whether the shrimplets are safe though.
  • As a self claimed 'aquatic gardener', I'm trying out some plant options in my layout. The Bolbitis is getting too big at the right wall, blocking the view too much. The back left side is still under consideration. I'm growing Pogostemon deccanensis, Limnophila aquatica and Myriophyllum matagrossense there to see which works best for me. But it might take 6 months to grow them big enough to make any conclusions. And I might swap the Ludwigia 'Mini Super Red' for Ludwigia repens for a bigger V shaped bush in the background.

As a temporary side hobby I'm developing my DIY Tank Monitor, with some devices which currently measure 24/7:
  • air pump intake CO2
  • CO2 and oxygen of the water via diffusion in a gas pocket (like a drop checker)
  • water conductivity
  • water temperature
  • light intensity
  • ambient air temperature and pressure
  • humidity and temperature in the hood
  • An upgraded pH sensor is in the making and my broken oxygen sensor is being replaced.
Things are slow and steady in my tank, which I like. But it's size (and some other smaller tanks) keeps me busy! :)
34 Replies · 4884 views
Mr.Shenanagins
Rockstar
Last reply · posted in Equipment Discussions
I am not as technically inclined as some members on here, but for those who are, answer me this. Could you not attach tubing to the end of this device where the sensor/probe is and run it into the aquarium in a similar fashion in which the drop checker works? Instead of waiting for a color change you could get an actual PPM reading? Please let me know if I am completely off base and why, or if this could possibly be a rudimentary way of getting more accurate co2 concentrations at a fraction of the cost of some high end equipment designed for submerged readings.

20 Replies · 1282 views
Nat
Nat
Last reply · posted in Aquascaping
Hi guys, I've been wondering about something.

I'm not really an aquascaper. I'm more of a rare plant collector, and I'm mostly into emersed plants and outdoor wildlife ponds. My aquarium is usually just a place where I experiment with different plants I've collected and stuff. But I'm interested in working at an aquascaping store one day, so I'm wondering what kind of things I should know.

I've watched some of Green Aqua's critiques of viewers' aquariums, but honestly, I find some of Tommy's comments a bit strange sometimes. He criticises certain things for being this or that, and so on. It got me thinking if there is a double standard here? Like, if Mr. Amano had made exactly the same aquascape, would people have had a completely different opinion? Would they see it as some kind of masterpiece?





It kind of reminds me of classical piano competitions, too. Imagine if a composer entered a competition and played their own compositions, but the judges didn't know who they were. They would get a bad score for sure, because music technique in their time wasn’t the same as now.

Now back to my question: Are there actually set rules in aquascaping, like ADA principles or other standards? And at what point do we get to develop our own styles rather than follow certain rules?
8 Replies · 121 views
  • Like
Reactions: GreggZ and NC AL
Nat
Nat
· posted in Planted Aquarium Discussion
I think we should be raising awareness about invasive species here. Looking at iNaturalist observations, the number of commercially available aquatic plants and animals that have become invasive species outside of their native ranges is insane. In areas without freezing winter, it is really impossible to stop it.

I think it might be better for aquatic plant companies to grow native plants, no? For example, you could have native plants that provide the growth forms needed in the hobby (say, strap-leaf plants) e.g. for South of the US, Sagittaria kurziana/filiformis alternative to Vallisneria nana. If there are no native plants available with a specific growth form, then non-native plants is okay. For example, you could replace invasive stem plants with similar-looking native plants, and aesthetically, nothing would really change, right? Or slow-medium growing non-native is okay imo (Cryptocoryne parva, Anubias barteri, Bucephalandra spp.)

Same with animal in the trade and popular pets really, I just follow ecologists and conservationists in a national park a lot, it still bothers me is the double standard in how we value animals. It sometimes seems that ideas of compassion and humane treatment apply mainly to cats and dogs, but not to horses, rabbits, chickens, pigs, reptiles or wildlife. If a cat or dog is harmed, people are quick to call it cruel and inhumane. But when those same animals kill native wildlife in a national park, attack livestock, injure other people's pets or threaten people. Sometimes even defending yourself against an attacking dog is seen as inhumane, whereas doing the same against a wild animal is considered acceptable. Why should being a popular companion animal determine how much compassion a creature deserves? Shouldn't animal welfare and humane treatment apply consistently to all animals, not just cats and dogs? For example cats killing stuffs people would say TNR (humane) but if some wildlife do the same it’s going to be instantly killed. The standards should be consistent, regardless of how emotionally popular an animal is. Personally, I support euthanasia for invasive animals, including fish, dogs, and cats, as controversial as that is.

The invasive plants seems to be easily estrablished here, fast enough to cover entire hill with it. We also have blackchin tilapia that escaped from an experiment run by a very rich company (rich enough to own the country), and it spread throughout the entire country.
I am also trying very hard to keep deadheading my non-native flowering plants, mainly Echinodorus species that I keep outdoors. E. cordifolius is very invasive here and can spread into waterways. I would say currently most of my pond plants outdoor are native species. And in the future it will be 100% native hopefully.
0 Replies · 17 views
Noahspapa
I Donated 2026
Last reply · posted in Planted Aquarium Discussion
Hello all. I just glued the hardscape in my new tank today. Tomorrow I’ll add substrate. And I’m up against the bane of my aquascaping existence. How to separate aquasoil from sand. I have plenty of rocks and filter floss. I even bought some flexible plastic barrier that I can’t get myself to actually use. Do any of you have a method that works for you you can share?
6 Replies · 77 views
  • Like
Reactions: davidkwilson
ample
Last reply · posted in Lounge
Saw a couple of you guys fighting for your lives over on Reddit. Valiant effort, but it’s just not the space for this hobby. Reddit will always be an open forum catering to the lowest common denominator. Nobody wants to see what years of focused practice produce, and will write off any decent aquascape or skilled plant husbandry as either having “thousands of dollars to spend” or just gatekeeping and elitism. Just let them have it. There’s no meaningful discussion to be had over there anyway.
45 Replies · 661 views
Koan
Staff member Supporting I Donated 2026 Rockstar
Last reply · posted in Planted Aquarium Discussion
20251224_113306.webp​

  • We grow super interesting plants here

  • Everybody has extra tank / filter / heaters around they've been meaning to get around to building into a farm tank...


naru-swap-2165936439.webp


It's easy!

TRIMMERS

Next time you have a big trim planned, or have just done: post a pic here of the plants!

Include the
  • species name
  • date cut / uprooted
  • expiration / you-will-toss after date
  • your zip code

TAKERS

Check cost of FedEx /UPS to your own address, and send the trimmer a PM with the offer to pay shipping 💯💯


word-done-stamp-letters-retro-grunge-design-composed-single-letter-stamps-vintage-isolated-wh...webp
37 Replies · 2291 views
Art
Art
Staff member I Donated 2026 Founding Member
Last reply · posted in Forum News/Feedback
This is the future home for the announcements when someone obtains an achievement badge. Let the games begin!
2066 Replies · 84943 views
  • Like
Reactions: Kwyet
JCole
Last reply · posted in New to Planted Aquariums? Post Here
Hey everyone,

I'm Josh (JCole on most of the reef forums). I've been in the saltwater side of the hobby for over 20 years, mostly running Acropora-dominant systems. I'm officially getting out of reef keeping and converting my current tank to a planted freshwater tank. I'll be honest up front: I know almost nothing about planted tanks. So I figured the best move was to introduce myself, start a build thread, and beg for help LOL.

A little background so you know a bit about my previous addiction! :-)

For a long stretch, my main tank was a 150-gallon Acro tank plumbed to a sump, a 20-gallon chaeto refugium, and a frag tank out in the garage. I crashed it in late 2020, lost over 70 Acros, and kept about six. Rebuilt it and kept going.

1794500161411.webp
1794499237529.webp
1794499244365.webp
1794499254374.webp
1794499262941.webp
1794499274577.webp
1794499283775.webp
1794499298026.webp
1794499308857.webp
1794500278516.webp

I eventually outgrew the 150 with coral colonies and needed to upgrade. My next tank was a 480-gallon acrylic peninsula, 8'x4'x2', with a 300-gallon stock tank sump in the garage.

1794499646141.webp
1794499661797.webp
1794499747467.webp
1794500100108.webp
1794500354960.webp

The aquarium was a dream aquarium of mine, but with having a full time job running a company with 3 boys in travel ball baseball, it consumed all of my time and I just could not give the tank what it actually needed and deserved. I eventually reset it, built my own cement rock and shelves, and sold the whole system in early 2025.

1794500867450.webp



After that, I downsized to a Marineland 180 (72x24x24) in the same room. This is the tank I'm converting to freshwater.

1794501194278.webp

WHERE I'M AT RIGHT NOW
  • Tank: Marineland 180, 72x24x24, glass.
  • Goal: High-tech planted. CO2, good light, fertilizers, the whole thing.
  • Cleaning: Done. I stripped the tank and sump with bleach and muriatic acid to get all the coralline algae off. It's clean and ready for water.
  • Sump: My Trigger Triton 44 sump is already set up and staying. I'm not going canister right now.
  • Controller: I've run an Apex for about 8 years, and I also wrote my own Raspberry Pi controller app that talks to the Apex and my Kasa, Shelly, and Jebao gear.
  • Lights: I pulled the halides and kept the pendants. For now, each pendant has a 120V LED grow light bulb in it.
  • Substrate: I have 19 bags of CaribSea Eco-Complete Planted ready to go.
WHERE I NEED HELP AND FEEDBACK
  1. CO2 with a sump: I know a sump gasses off CO2. Since I'm keeping mine, what tips do you have to keep the loss down (lower the return, cover the sump, change the overflow, anything else)?
  2. CO2 control: I can run a solenoid and a pH probe off the Apex or my own app. Do you control CO2 by pH, by a timer, or both? Is a drop checker still the thing to trust? And what do you use to actually get the CO2 into 180 gallons—an inline reactor on the return or diffusers? What safeguards do you run so a stuck solenoid doesn't gas the fish overnight?
  3. Lighting: Are LED grow bulbs in the pendants enough for a high-tech 72" long, 24" deep tank, or is that a stopgap? If I upgrade, what would you put over it?
  4. Substrate and hardscape: I read that people put lava rock in filter bags on the bottom to build up hills and slopes so the deep rooting plants get more depth. Is that the way to do it, and how deep should the Eco-Complete be on top? Is 19 bags enough for what I'm trying to do?
  5. Fertilizers: EI or lean dosing for a first-timer? I'm used to dosing two-part and testing a lot, so numbers do not scare me.
  6. Plants and fish: I want to start with beginner plants, but I'm not scared to try the harder stuff. Acros taught me patience, so I'd like to work up to the more advanced plants. What would you start with in a 72" high-tech tank, and what would you add later? And what fish do well in that setup?
  7. Water: I've always run RODI for the reef. For planted, do I use straight tap, RO with remineralizer, or a blend? Which GH and KH numbers should I be shooting for?
  8. Cycling: Plants change how you cycle, right? What's the order of operations?
Fair warning, I'm a gear nerd and I tend to wing it, so feel free to tell me when I'm about to do something dumb. I'll keep this thread updated as I go.

Any help or guidance would be appreciated.

Thank you!!!

Will be continued!
118 Replies · 2826 views
gnatster
Supporting I Donated 2026
Last reply · posted in Planted Aquarium Discussion
Since these are starting, here's a thread.

Starbond, the makers of Cyanocrylate Adhesives, has a few items on sale. Black Friday Starts Early 2026 | Starbond. I'm a fan of their Clog Prevention Stoppers. There are some sanding discs on sale for the woodworkers in the crowd too.
25 Replies · 1534 views
Back
Top