Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

Social Feed

CFassett
Last reply · posted in Journals

Journal  The 75 Garden

Hi all, while I have had accounts for a variety of forums, I believe this will be my first ever post to any forum, anywhere. I've been exclusively a Facebook hobbyist for years and some of you may know me from there. I assume I can have more than one build thread, I have two tanks, so I'd like to keep separate threads for each. I'll be figuring out the quirks and limitations of forum posting along the way.

I am very much on the cheap end of the hobby, so my 75 (the largest tank I've ever owned) is a basic Aqueon tank from Petco's 50% sale. The stand is made from construction lumber. I'm active in the woodworking hobby as well, though I haven't finished my workbench yet, hopefully this summer...
I used the standard 2x4 design, and I'm never doing it again. 2x4 frames are an extremely inefficient way to utilize the materials and space. Sheet goods are superior, and the cost differences aren't significant. For more information, you'll have to wait for my 10 gallon build thread.

To anyone that is going to make a 2x4 stand (or any DIY stand, tbh), I have two main bits of advice:
  1. Use glue. Modern wood glue is stronger than the wood itself. Applying glue to each mating surfaces does more for the strength of the stand than all of the hardware combined. I always viewed glue as being somehow inferior in years past but a quality wood glue is amazing stuff.
  2. If you use glue for each surface, and you use good joinery (or faux-joinery, in the case of the corners) to transfer the weight of the tank to the floor without hanging on anything, then you can build the whole thing out of 1x4 and be fine. Go look at commercial stands, whether they be Oase, Waterbox, Petco, whatever, they all use 1x4s and sheet goods. 2x4s are pointless.
20220912_214936.jpg20220929_071021.jpg

I used hardboard facing and paint for a simple finish. The doors were the most difficult bit. At the last minute I decided to inset a bit of plywood for a back, rather than leaving it open, and I'm happy with the decision. It protects the whole stand against racking forces and provides locations for mounting auxiliary equipment.

20221026_095755.jpg
20221026_100128.jpg

I applied a black privacy film background, since fish expand their chromatophores in darker environments, resulting in more vivid coloration. I also like the contrast.
20221026_095736.jpg



Filtration: two canister filters, a SunSun 370 GPH and an Oase Biomaster Thermo 600 (350 GPH) for a total nominal hourly turnover rate of 9.6.
Filter Fittings: Aquario Neo with venturi skimmers, shrimp guards, and lily-type outputs.
CO₂: Two reactors, one on each output, run from a GLA Pro-DS-2 regulator, 5 lb cylinder. I have a flowmeter and pH controller that I'll be installing this summer.
Substrate: Master Soil Next, Powder, Black
Light: Chihiros WRGB II (OG)

This tank was replacing a 16 gallon tank that I had built from a bit of acrylic I had been given. I went ahead and transferred the plants and fish and prepared for the ammonia spike.20221030_172103.jpg20221031_153856.jpg20221108_194117.jpg

The Pogostemon helferi var. 'Downoi' melted to nothing, but there were no other casualties. The ammonia spike came quickly, but my tap water has 0 dKH, so it naturally sits around 6.8. The substrate buffered it further down to 6.0, and with CO₂, down to 5.0. The temperature in the tank is 76°F (24°C). At that temperature and pH, ammonia is extremely non-toxic, it's almost entirely unionized ammonium. Ionized free ammonia tolerance varies by species, but starts to be of concern at about 0.02 mg/L. At 24°C, and 5.0 and 6.0, the Total Ammonia Nitrogen (TAN) reading necessary to yeild 0.02 mg/L of free ammonia is 375 and 40 mg/L, respectively.
So, I didn't worry about the ammonia. I did no water changes, I just let it do its thing, and I lost no fish. The stocking at the time included Sundadanio goblinus, Microdevario kubotai, (two species that are generally considered "sensitive") and an alien Betta.
20221102_205357.jpg
It took much longer than I had expected for the tank to process the ammonia. I had used the filter media from the 16 gallon predecessor, so I thought it would be over in a week. I hadn't counted on how much phosphate my substrate would devour. I finally set up my auto-doser and mixed salts, and suddenly, my fish were all gasping at the surface. I was confused, I had added lids at the same time and I thought that the lids were blocking the oxygenation of the water. I fiddled with it for a day or two and then tested my water. I finally had nitrites.

I started my foray into the aquarium hobby in Utah in 2012. In all those years, cycling a tank had been simple, though unforgiving. 7.8 pH, 18 dGH, 15 dKH, 350-450 TDS, it was liquid rock. Nitrifiers never experienced nutrient deficiencies and grew rapidly, but ammonia was very toxic, so any little bump in the cycle and fish died. I moved to North Carolina in November of 2020.

Here, the TDS of the tap water is 37. The only thing in our water is the calcium hydroxide (slaked lime) that the water company adds to prevent plumbing corrosion. The pH straight out of the tap is typically 9.5-ish, but it offgasses to 6.8 within 24 hours sitting out, and within seconds of being added to an active tank full of humic, tannic, nitric, and carbonic acids. When the hydroxide offgasses, all that's left is a bit of calcium. I haven't been able to nail down the exact reason, but the API GH test overestimates my hardness significantly. I have good reason to believe that my GH is about 1.5 dGH (all calcium, no magnesium) but the API test always returns 5 dGH. My current running theory is that the API test measures the calcium only (this is actually quite common among GH tests) and then assumes a "normal/average" ratio of calcium and magnesium (1 part calcium to 2 parts magnesium) and therefore can overstate the GH by a factor of 3 if no magnesium is present.

Anyways, that was a bit of a tangent. When I came to North Carolina, I discovered that nitrifiers frequently experience nutrient deficiencies in this incredibly pure water. In particular, phosphate deficiencies. In every tank previously in NC, a bit of fertilizer was all it took, but this was my first experience with an aquasoil devouring my phosphates. It wasn't until my autodoser was adding KH₂PO₄ on a daily basis that my cycle finally got unstuck.

Nitrite poisoning and CO₂ poisoning act the same way, both of them bypass the selective uptake channels and pumps within the gills. They ower the pH of the blood, converting oxygen-carrying hemoglobin into non-oxygen-carrying met-hemoglobin— a condition called methemoglobinemia. It's the same reason benzocaine products like Orajel are no longer approved for use with teething pain in infants, as it can also cause methemoglobinemia (blue-baby syndrome). The Root Effect in fish functions a bit differently than the Bohr Effect in most vertebrates, and again it functions differently in invertebrates that posses cyanoglobin as opposed to hemoglobin.

Anyways, the point is that nitrite poisoning and CO₂ poisoning are additive. So I just turned the CO₂ down for a few days, added some Prime, and watched the fish. I turned it back up once the nitrite portion of the cycle passed, a little less than a week.

And so this was the rather humble start of my 75 gallon journey. I'll try to be less long-winded in my next post bringing it up to its current state.20221206_195422.jpg
4 Replies · 1571 views
nivliw
· posted in Planted Aquarium Discussion
Hello guys what could be the cause of pale new growth?
0 Replies · 12 views
P
Rockstar
Last reply · posted in Planted Aquarium Discussion
Following @Dennis Wong advise to hold growth variables as steady as possible to avoid transition stress has been my single greatest tool to aquatic plant success.

I am fortunate to have Tap Water that is consistent all season with 6 ppm Ca, 1 ppm Mg day in day out all year. It is consistent because the water utility adds most of the Calcium and Magnesium in it.. the source water is extremely soft. The head of the water department has told me it never gets close to their target. They continually test and adjust the feed to hit target.

It is simple enough for me to just add gypsum and epsom salt to boost it to what I want.

Helping a fellow member here who is starting a 75 gallon tank in an apartment. Ro unit is simply not an option for him in the apartment for now. schlepping bottles of RO for a 75 gallon would also be a hardship. It is a tank just for family enjoyment and not intended to be a competition tank. He will be dosing diy ferts, high light and co2.

His public water supply has an average DGH of 8 with reasonable calcium magnesium balance. But the Seasonal variation is between 4.5 DGH and 11.2 DGH…

In the situation where RO is not currently an option what would peoples responses be?

At 8 DGH steady throughout the year, I would probably just go with it.

It would be easy enough to test tap water DGH before doing a water change. It would be easy enough to create a table to alter how much to-adjust gypsum and epsom salts as tap water hardness decreases with seasonal shifts down to 4.5. But the question is for the times it hops upwards to high end of range.

One could schlepp bottles for those weeks and hope those weeks are outliers…

Or one could simply target a higher DGH all of the time in the interest of stability..

So I understand the potential issues, but not enough of what numbers matter…

Am I overthinking? I know @Dennis Wong has said the Carbonate hardness has a bigger impact on plant health than General Hardness,

Is ranging General Hardness less of a concern?

Water report indicates 3.5 DKH with no report regarding seasonal variation..
15 Replies · 178 views
Kwyet
Supporting I Donated 2026 Rockstar
Last reply · posted in Journals
Edit: Newest tank starts here: Journal - Kwyet’s 125 / now 140G Nature Tank

——

This was one of the first tanks I set back up when we moved into our new house. As such, it was done very quickly so I could get it re-cycled and the fish in ASAP. Surprisingly, even though the filter sponges were just kept damp in plastic bags for 4 days, cycling took less than a week. I was NOT going to try to catch the pictus catfishes again, so I just lowered the water level in their holding tubs and poured them in. These guys are vocal when annoyed, so I assure you that I could hear them cussing at me, lol!

Here’s one of the last pictures of the tank before moving:

IMG_4397.jpeg

And here is what it looked like after the move in August 2024:

IMG_6088.jpeg

It left a lot to be desired, and while the painted blue background looked fine with my blue walls in Florida, it doesn’t look as good here with beige walls. I wasn’t going to move it out and scrape away the paint though, so it is what it is.

At this point I believe it had 1 angelfish (kept because it swims off-kilter), 1 Denison barb (kept because of a small white growth on chin since it was a baby), 2 old bronze Cory cats (because of age), and 3 Spotted Pictus catfish (because they were hard to acquire), 2 Super Red Bristlenose Plecos and 1 Glo-fish Rainbow shark (just because, lol!).

More to come.
76 Replies · 7255 views
hamfist
Last reply · posted in Planted Aquarium Discussion
I asked this question in a recent thread but it received no traction, so maybe it deserves its own thread. .........

When planting newly received emersed growth stem plants could it not be beneficial to leave the leaves on the stem of the section to be buried ? Yes these leaves will rot but could this not be possibly providing a useful ammonia source for the newly introduced plant and promote root development etc ? What evidence do we actually have of the pros and cons of doing this ? I must admit that do trim as Naturescapes_Rocco has suggested in another thread, by removing all leaves apart from a small top section but every time I do, it always makes me wonder about this factor.

I can see all the benefits of not leaving any excess emersed growth leaves on the exposed part of the stem but on the actual buried part of the stem could it possibly be even beneficial ??
5 Replies · 74 views
Vis123
Last reply · posted in Aquascaping
Long-time lurker in the hobby. I’ve been chewing on an idea for a website (maybe a weekly newsletter too) that’s focused purely on curated aquascape inspiration — not another feed to scroll, but something with an actual point of view: why a scape works, what makes the hardscape/planting choices interesting, styles worth studying, that kind of thing.

Before I build anything, wanted to ask people who’d actually use it:

• Where do you currently go for aquascape inspiration — Instagram, YouTube, forums, contest archives?

• Does that already fully scratch the itch, or is there something missing (context, explanation, curation vs. just a feed)?

• Would a smaller, curated site/newsletter add anything for you, or does it feel redundant with what’s already out there?

• Would you ever visit or subscribe to something like that regularly, or is it a “look at once, forget” kind of thing?

Genuinely trying to figure out if this fills a real gap or if I’d just be adding noise to a space that’s already well served. All takes welcome, including “this already exists” or “nobody needs this.”
3 Replies · 58 views
Simba3000
Last reply · posted in Equipment Discussions
This is my first time using a reactor. I have a Landen 100p (40x18x18 inches) and just received my Aqua Rocks Colorado Stainless Yugang Reactor. I had a spare Eheim 4+ 350 so it's now hooked to that with just foam filtration. My other filter is an Oase Biomaster Thermo 600 with an 850 head. I'm a little confused on the initial setup. I have my Co2 turning on at 9:30am, lights on 12-8pm. I have the offsets at 50% of the reactor, and the surface area is 4 inches larger than the calculations said I needed.

I know that contact time is the factor so my Eheim is about 50% flow. Do I initially increase the Co2 rate to purge the air out of the reactor, then dial it back so i'm seeing off-gassing every minute once I'm reaching my ppm? I'm using a Co2 Art Elite Pro regulator. My psi sits between 35-40 on a 20lb tank. Co2 is easy for me to get and cheap so I'm not concerned with excess. There's not a lot of information I can find on these so anything helps. Thanks for reading!
3 Replies · 97 views
Art
Art
Staff member I Donated 2026 Founding Member
· posted in Meet & Greet Forum
Welcome to ScapeCrunch, @dmitrysokolovvet!
We would love to get to know you. Please tell us about yourself. What tank do you have?
0 Replies · 11 views
Vis123
· posted in Aquascaping
Long-time lurker in the hobby. I’ve been chewing on an idea for a website (maybe a weekly newsletter too) that’s focused purely on curated aquascape inspiration — not another feed to scroll, but something with an actual point of view: why a scape works, what makes the hardscape/planting choices interesting, styles worth studying, that kind of thing.

Before I build anything, wanted to ask people who’d actually use it:

• Where do you currently go for aquascape inspiration — Instagram, YouTube, forums, contest archives?

• Does that already fully scratch the itch, or is there something missing (context, explanation, curation vs. just a feed)?

• Would a smaller, curated site/newsletter add anything for you, or does it feel redundant with what’s already out there?

• Would you ever visit or subscribe to something like that regularly, or is it a “look at once, forget” kind of thing?

Genuinely trying to figure out if this fills a real gap or if I’d just be adding noise to a space that’s already well served. All takes welcome, including “this already exists” or “nobody needs this.”
0 Replies · 30 views
Art
Art
Staff member I Donated 2026 Founding Member
· posted in Meet & Greet Forum

Hello  Welcome, Vis123

Welcome to ScapeCrunch, @Vis123!
We would love to get to know you. Please tell us about yourself. What tank do you have?
0 Replies · 21 views
Naturescapes_Rocco
Supporting I Donated 2026 Rockstar Article Contributor
Last reply · posted in Do It Yourself (DIY)
This is not a step by step tutorial, more for inspiration and general information!

My very first DIY stand was a 100cm two-door home-depot plywood stand. It looks fine in pictures, but was NOT up to the insanely high, unhealthy standards of excellence that I hold myself to with everything:
1786934599904.webp

1786934613299.webp1786934620976.webp
No journal for this old tank.

The lesson here was: don’t use home depot plywood! It sucks. Find a real plywood dealer and spend the extra $.

My next stand was way more ambitious: a 150cm x 60cm stand, designed to hold up 2400+ lbs, made from quality baltic birch plywood. 3 doors, two interior weight-bearing vertical panels, adjustable leveling feet. It worked great, and can be seen in my two journals Many Lessons and Inert Sand Trials:

1786934772518.webp1786934791132.webp1786934973457.webp
I did a WAY better job on this stand, and it now resides with @Kwyet ! Also, a spray finish really makes a big difference.

After that, the 90cm Experiment Tank stand. Two doors, and instead of a cumbersome middle panel, I used one hefty plywood column:

1786935041376.webp1786935056624.webp
Scottish accent Fookin' crispay

1786934993530.webp1786935011283.webp

This tank also had a waterproof, sealed bottom “rim” so up to 2cm of water would have to fill the stand bottom before it overflows. Useful for emergencies or leaks, when combined with loud water leak alarms! This stand and tank is in my garage, soon to be sold to anyone in Colorado who wants it!

The new 120cm stand:​


This stand is for my new 120cm tank! This stand is the culmination of seven years of stand-making. All of my mistakes, lessons, preferences, and skills were combined to make the stand of my dreams!

And of course, I had to move homes and got seriously injured, requiring surgery, while I was trying to finish it. Sorry for the lack of pictures!

I would not say this design is beginner friendly. It’s not expert, but likely intermediate difficulty. I have a Wen track saw and a Sawstop PCS Cabinet saw, which changes the entire process compared to someone working with more difficult tools. I also have a Graco Magnum X7 paint sprayer for a professional paint finish.

First, I started with mocking up the stand in Shapr3D, my modeling program:
1786935204390.webp1786935207589.webp

My local lumber company had really good deals on 5x5’ sheets of ¾” baltic birch plywood.

IT IS CRITICAL for precision woodworking like this (no trim to cover up mistakes) to get exact measurements, particularly for the thickness of the plywood. For example, using a pair of digital calipers, this 3/4" plywood was 17.8mm thick (0.7 in a lot smaller than .75"), which is what I used in my modeling program to create the exact length of cuts to properly span 120cm long and 60cm deep.

I collected the exact measurements of each part needed, and threw it into Opticutter to determine how to best cut my 5x5’ plywood sheets:
1786935316418.webp1786935318657.webp
1786935322579.webp
You don't need to study these sheets; the photos are just to show you how Opticutter works to save you from creating too much waste, and using the fewest cuts!

Steps I followed for this stand:​

  1. Cut all panels using table/track saw.
  2. Make 4-ply support column. Make notch cut ~145mm from top of column to fit behind front brace. Glue and trim/clean.
  3. Cut out "access holes" in panels, including pocket holes for front and back brace, predrilled holes for front brace (in middle, and upper portion for future front panel) and predrilled holes for back panel. Use a router with roundover bit to create round, smooth holes for cord and tubing access, as well as handles for moving the stand around!
  4. Run the "standing height "of the side and back panels (and 4-ply center column) through table saw to make uniform height for all 4 parts. All of these 4 parts should be cut to the exactly same height.
  5. Trim door “finger-pull” with a router. Just a 45-degree "slice" off the door's corner to make a finger pull.
  6. To assemble: Flip top upside down, test fit sides and back, secure with screws. Make front edge flush, back can be trimmed down with router flush bit if necessary.
  7. Attach the bottom panel, Make front edge flush, as the back can be trimmed down.
  8. Add 4-ply column, ensure front edge flush.
  9. Add front and back "braces".
  10. Add front panel, and bottom "lips" that hold any spilled water in.
  11. Spray and sand stand, fill gaps with Bondo wood filler. Sand and repeat until corners, cracks and divots are smooth.
  12. Caulk the inner corners where water would be.
  13. Paint stand and doors.
  14. Attach doors.
  15. Add feet.
  16. Run electrical and LED strips.
  17. Cut foam mat to size.
Here's some of the steps in the modeling program:


4-plywood-thick center column, with "notch" for the front brace to fit flush:
1786935608727.webp

Top down first on a flat, even surface, then add sides and back:
1786935663370.webp


Flip right-side-up, and add the bottom panel:
1786935668910.webp


Add the rear brace, the front brace, and the center column. Make sure the front brace and column are flush with the front of the top/back panel edges.
1786935699585.webp

Add the front panel and bottom lip pieces:
1786935739396.webp

For the doors, create a notched finger pull (side view):
1786935777523.webp

Door hinge stuff:

And it's done! Here's some of the few pictures I DID take of this process, sorry! I had a lot going on:

Gluing the 4-ply-thick center column:
1786935839650.webp

To make the access holes in the back and side panels, I 3D printed some plastic guides for my router bit to follow, then roughly cut the inside out so the router had less material to work through:
1786935934796.webp

Perfect routered holes:
1786935947146.webp


I learned to score the plywood with my box cutter first, so when it chipped from the rough jigsaw cut, it chipped ONLY to the scored lines:
1786936020425.webp1786936029954.webp


I removed the excess interior material with the jigsaw, then routered. I also used a roundover bit (in process on the left hole, right hole not rounded):
1786936050569.webp
Any chips or imperfections could be fixed later with bondo wood filler and sanding.


Once I had my access holes cut out, I could assemble! I used clamps to hold the panels together and flush, used an Incra T-Rule (amazing device) to mark a line that was the middle of my plywood panel's core:
1786936210829.webp


Then, I drilled countersink holes with this bit for the screw heads to sit below the level of the wood:

1786936271554.webp

Screws:
Since the screws on the top, bottom, and rear of the stand would never be visible, I decided to skip the annoying "pocket screw and glue" scenario and just go with crazy robust torx-head 1.5” construction screws. I LOVED it. Definitely my preferred method, though they really do require pre-drilling AND drilling countersink heads. Still, way stronger than pocket screws my god.


Wood filling and Priming:
Bondo wood filler is amazing stuff. I used TONS of it, this was just the first pass:
1786936338801.webp
Apply, sand, apply more, sand more.


Then I primed with Sherwin Williams Gallery Series primer, and sprayed with a TrueAirless 515 tip in my Magnum X7:
1786936484035.webp

Once the primer was dry, I sanded it, and sprayed again. Once dry, sanded again. Lots of sanding:
1786936507207.webp


I wiped the tank down with tack cloth, then went for the finishing coat using a Graco FFLP 310 Tip and Sherwin-Williams Gallery Series Waterborne Topcoat in true black. Probably a matte or satin sheen, I can’t recall. Not cheap, good paint! Make sure to filter your paint through a find mesh before spraying.
1786936524533.webp


By far the best, most perfect finish I've ever had on a stand. BTW, the doors are fully adjustable up, down, left and right to get them nicely aligned. Blum hinges rock!
1786936554178.webp


Once it was all put together, I got some help to move it into the new house. And installed the oversized Aquarium Mat.

I paid Tommy, the owner of Aqua Rocks Colorado, a delivery fee to have my custom 120x60x50cm tank delivered and installed on the stand. Once positioned evenly around all sides, I trimmed the aquarium mat with an Xacto knife, and was finished!

I'm tired today, but I'll upload more pics of this stand soon to this thread and to the 120cm Journal, too!

Questions? Ask below! I love to help out.​

6 Replies · 233 views
Back
Top