Week 11
I have been front dosing the macros for a few weeks now, and I follow the PPS pro medium light method:
7ppm N
0.7ppm PO4
9.31ppm K
0.7ppm Mg
0.35ppm Fe(and other trace minerals)
And I'm curious as to how much nutrient the plants have been using throughout the week. I only have API test kits on hand and can only test nitrogen, so I gave that a try before and after water change and dosing. Before testing, I followed Gregg's calculation to find out theoretically how much nitrogen would be in the water column not accounting for any nitrogen generated and uptake, which is around 25ppm with weekly 20% water change.
Then I tested the water right before water change, and ~10 minutes after front loading the macros post water change. It was very difficult to read the color from the test kit. To my best judgement, before water change, we are sitting at around 10ppm. After dosing, the color was darker but i think would be somewhere between 10-20ppm.
Then I used the same chart that Gregg made again, this time putting in different numbers in Weekly Nutrient Uptake, to eventually match the number I had from testing the water. It was also difficult to adjust for plant growth difference, as the plant mass probably expanded I don't even know how many times.
Here's a comparison of week 1 and week 11 for reference:
Nitrogen generated in tank was probably on the lower side at this moment, I only recently added 8 fish in along with the few dozens of shrimp that are mostly newborn second generation, and a bunch of snails. I don't feed often and my best guess is maybe ~2ppm of nitrogen is produced weekly.
Accounting for all the various factor, it's hard to get a more accurate estimate unless I test for a few more weeks, and would probably need a better test kit as well. But I am guessing that they currently use between 5-7ppm of nitrogen weekly, and makes me wonder if I should increase my dose to "highlight", which will double what I currently dose.