Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

There’s a dumpster fire happening on r/Aquascape

Also someone told me my scapes were "average", and people agreed. Like cmon now. I'm no expert but I think I'm a bit above the average hobbyist, I'd hope...
This is the one comment that nearly made me spit out my drink when I read it. Didn't they also say your tanks were barely aquascapes. I considered commenting on that one but decided best to avoid the drama.
 
I’ve never been on Reddit. Reading all this - it sounds horrible. All I spend time with is this forum, YouTube, apple podcast and instagram. I created a FB account but don’t really do anything with it. My wife maintains a family FB account which keeps us to date with friends, etc. I’d just like to say that this crew is incredible. I’m very blessed that Jeff Miotke pointed me to you all. Many thanks to Jeff and you all!
 
All I could think all day was was:

View attachment 21778

My wording on my post wasn't thought out, and I came to agree with most of the grievances people took with my post (and even came to understand them), but DAMN. I didn't attack anyone, but people sure wanted to attack me lol

I was called elitist, clown, asshole, dick, gatekeeper, pretentious. Yikes, I've never been called those things in my life! I'm pretty sure I'm NOT those things, but holy moly the hivemind of Reddit did not like it.

Also someone told me my scapes were "average", and people agreed. Like cmon now. I'm no expert but I think I'm a bit above the average hobbyist, I'd hope...

I know I wasn't alone in my expressed sentiment, but the sheer number of bad faith arguments and assumptions about what I meant was mindblowing. I shouldn't have mentioned anything about beginners... it's not beginners that were ruining the quality of the community, it's the extremely low-quality, low-effort, and/or unrelated post that beginners began flooding the sub with. Years ago, it genuine wasn't like that. That's what I was trying to have a discussion around, and see if we could step up and prevent. But my wording genuinely triggered people as if I had personally attacked them, despite the fact that the Mods of the sub implemented basically many little changes aligned with what I suggested?? They just used better language than I did, and people loved it.

Users hyperfixated on the title, didn't read anything else I commented or posted, threw insults, and called for me to be banned?? So, not much will change. That community will stay a slightly higher end clone of r/plantedtank and other facebook groups, but I don't think I'll be participating much anymore. I don't mind helping beginners, but if I'm going to spend my precious time on this planet looking at a screen, I like to spend it looking at tanks or scapes that inspire me (like so, so many countless tanks here do!). I DON'T follow facebook groups, or r/plantedtank because the quality just isn't there.

Does that mean I think those groups should be deleted? wtf, no. But that's the kind of logic that redditors used on my post yesterday...

I fully agree with @ample and basically everyone in discussion here:


There's so much misinformation spread in that community already. If I read "excess nutrients" from a very amateur scaper one more time...
😭
Oh man I can't believe I missed it! I bet that post was a good read! :D Wish I would have seen it before you took it down.
 
I thought that there was actually also a good amount of support and that the mods seem to think seriously about your points.

The problem in the internet era is that it just takes a few bad eggs to spread the rot. 99% of folks may be perfectly reasonable, but the 1% of crazy folks is enough bend the experience, especially if they are the most vocal ones. Think about the whole trace tox saga, or the plantedtank forum mod drama etc, its literally 1 or 2 ppl on forums driving everyone else nuts. In a group of 1000, 1% crazy will yield 10 people - and when 10 ppl are shouting at you it may seem like a lot, but statistically, its really nothing.

I saw your post getting a couple of hundred upvotes - say 20% of folks disagree with you, you would expect at least 20-40 ppl yelling at you. Its still a tiny figure by ratio - and its a fair trade for the post you made. Think of how poorly run the average tank is, and 50% of folks are below average. Of course any comment on averages is bound to draw a strong response. And of course the most butt hurt folks will be the ones posting replies, or counter posts.

Anyone that participates in public discourse or exhibition on the internet will eventually have to deal with crazy folks. We should be just mindful of how the statistics of such things play out.

I think the /aquascaping sub is already quite a bit better in aquascaping and plant growing than the generic /aquariums or /plantedtank reddits, all things considered. TBH, its already quite a bit above my expectations for reddit - already, its way ahead of facebook groups which are the absolutely dumpster for bad planted aquarium advice.
 
I tried to help some of the genius on fb groups ugh but I have given up! all I get is hate if I try it seems. Newbies know more than tom barr lol. Yeah wash your wood and plants with dawn to clean them was told literally lmao no joke! Just keep buying your carbon filters suckers it will fix your problems. Need to sell a filter with trump head on it will fix all the problems u have. Hell u may have republican and democratic fish in you tank they need seperate tanks maybe that's your problems 😆 I swear if It would sell anymore. Its a dumb world out there! Heard manager of PetSmart tell people they need some baking soda to lower there ph, uh no stupid wrong! and this isn't a swimming pool idiots I give up!
 
Last edited:
I thought that there was actually also a good amount of support and that the mods seem to think seriously about your points.

The problem in the internet era is that it just takes a few bad eggs to spread the rot. 99% of folks may be perfectly reasonable, but the 1% of crazy folks is enough bend the experience, especially if they are the most vocal ones. Think about the whole trace tox saga, or the plantedtank forum mod drama etc, its literally 1 or 2 ppl on forums driving everyone else nuts. In a group of 1000, 1% crazy will yield 10 people - and when 10 ppl are shouting at you it may seem like a lot, but statistically, its really nothing.
But father fish said u don't need new water just clean u old water and put it back into tank. lol my fav quote I've heard online dam genius's online anymore. why the hell did I buy a filter when I can reuse my old water I must be nuts! walstad method is still my fav in the end. NO water changes EVER! 😆
 
On the flip side, recently on a fish focused forum, a member posted about his wild caught altum angelfish dying after he put them in tap water with a pH of 7.8-8.0, 250 ppm hardness and people said "it's not your fault" WTF? It's 1000% percent his fault. 10 minutes of research would have prevented that tragedy and he gets consolation for being too damn lazy to do any research that would prevent the death of wild caught living creatures but it's not PC to call them out on that forum. So if he can't learn from his mistake he'll just repeat it. This hobby is becoming garbage .
 
experts have gotten tired of the culture of misinformation and mediocrity a long time ago and stopped bothering with Reddit.
I don't consider myself an "expert" but this is me over in the orchid forum on Reddit. It is a constant stream of people asking, How do I save this dying plant. I've grown literally thousands of orchids, I have AOS awards, I have local orchid show awards, I have my own hybrids registered with the RHS in England. On Reddit, I'm competing with "experts" who grow 4 plants in their windowsill armed with TikTok knowledge who debate me and tell me I'm wrong. I don't bother most of the time. Its not worth the frustration.
 
I don't consider myself an "expert" but this is me over in the orchid forum on Reddit. It is a constant stream of people asking, How do I save this dying plant. I've grown literally thousands of orchids, I have AOS awards, I have local orchid show awards, I have my own hybrids registered with the RHS in England. On Reddit, I'm competing with "experts" who grow 4 plants in their windowsill armed with TikTok knowledge who debate me and tell me I'm wrong. I don't bother most of the time. It’s not worth the frustration.
I’m also in the orchid sub but I’m not sure why, because every day it’s hundreds of the same posts of dyed and dying phals. I’m not even close to being an expert but it’s so exhausting. I think one of the only subs that can maintain advanced hobbyists is the baking, bread, and sourdough. There’s still tons of beginner posts and occasionally some drama, but the pros are generally well respected.
 
But father fish said u don't need new water just clean u old water and put it back into tank. lol my fav quote I've heard online dam genius's online anymore. why the hell did I buy a filter when I can reuse my old water I must be nuts! walstad method is still my fav in the end. NO water changes EVER! 😆
The Walstad method has such a chokehold on the Reddit crowd it’s insane. In general, I find Reddit aquarists to be strongly anti CO2 and allergic to water changes or maintenance. Yet they obsess over “parameters” while simultaneously refusing to believe that nitrates aren’t the only measure of nutrient level and aquarium health. Omg and can someone explain the obsession with capping aquasoil with sand over there? Lots of weird ideas being passed around as gospel.
 
Last edited:

Top 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top