Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

Journal First Aquascape

Wow! Three months since last update. To be honest, I might not be providing an update today if not for the fact @Burr740 started a turf war. He called out non-Dutch style tanks as worthless piles of rocks and wood with easy slow growing epiphytes and moss. He basically said they were a complete waste of time and an embarrassment to planted tanks. At least that's what I read (JUST JOKING JOE. Please don't stop sending me free plants 😊)

Seriously though, while I may not spend as much time working on this as those with Dutch style tanks (or maybe I do, I don't know since I haven't done that style yet), it does take up a lot of time, and it's only 90X50X45. Because everything tends to grow at different rates, I tend to do big maintenance in sections or quadrants. A couple weeks ago I pulled most all the Phoenix moss out because it was getting too thick and full on all the branches/rocks and starting to turn brown underneath and harboring a lot of detritus. I also pulled most background stems in the back left and replanted fresh cuttings, including a few new plants. About a month ago, I pulled most of the AR mini because the Amanos had been going to town on it (I pulled the Amanos as well). Obviously, it didn't take long for the new AR mini stems to take off, as they clearly need to be trimmed as well. I swear AR Mini might be the easiest red plant to grow. The right side of the tank tends to turn into a jungle quickly, so I'll be trimming that next weekend and hopefully, that will be timed well for it and the left side to get back in sync.

One of the problems I still have with the tank is moss getting down into the front hairgrass carpet and choking it out. You can see it in this picture even though I just pulled a lot out yesterday. It's a big reason I'm hesitant to use much moss on future tanks, even though I think it has strong visual and natural appeal.

The tank is now 15 months old and I plan to keep it going for at least another 6 while I work on the basement remodel and other scapes.

 
Last edited:
Curious to know how frequently you top off the p.Decannensis.
I've found that early on, it needs trimmed at least once a month, maybe twice, however, it's growth tends to slow after awhile. As you noted on your tank, over time, the lower parts tend to get rather bare and unsightly, in fact. what you see in this photo was completely uprooted and replanted not long ago for that very reason. Also, per what you mentioned on your journal, I think it does tend to branch and show more compact growth under different conditions. I think it may be partly do to lighting (this tank gets higher par than my farm tank had been getting until recently) and perhaps also how you plant it. I plant it in this tank with individual stems 1/4 to 1/2 an inch apart and only place 3-4 of them. In my farm tank I planted maybe 5 all very close together.

That is a tall pinnatifida!
Yes, it may be the fastest growing plant in this tank. In my farm tank, it and Myriophyllum Roraima battle it out for fastest growth.
 
Last edited:
Wow! Three months since last update. To be honest, I might not be providing an update today if not for the fact @Burr740 started a turf war. He called out non-Dutch style tanks as worthless piles of rocks and wood with easy slow growing epiphytes and moss. He basically said they were a complete waste of time and an embarrassment to planted tanks. At least that's what I read (JUST JOKING JOE. Please don't stop sending me free plants 😊)

Yeah man thats my bad. I see how my comment mightve hurt your feelings. To make amends Id like to send you my new restart formula (working title) free of charge. I havent mentioned it in public yet but Im pretty excited about it. Think of it as a quick primer to get things right before starting my ferts. I believe itd be perfect for your tank

Just add the entire contents, wait 24 hours, then remove any leaves that are in bad shape. Thats it!

Jays Restart Formula.webp
 
Lol you know very well I meant tanks that are all hardscape, once the hardscape is in place, theyre done. Those tanks have little to do with "aquatic gardening". Clearly thats not your tank. You just happen to have a little wood in the mix, along with lots and lots of plants that DO need tending to

And youre doing a great job too! I know verterans that cant grow AR that smooth and flat. As for the moss, yeah that just comes with it. Gotta be vigillant about picking up any scrap piece you see. Even then itll be taking hold somewhere
 
Yeah man thats my bad. I see how my comment mightve hurt your feelings. To make amends Id like to send you my new restart formula (working title) free of charge. I havent mentioned it in public yet but Im pretty excited about it. Think of it as a quick primer to get things right before starting my ferts. I believe itd be perfect for your tank

Just add the entire contents, wait 24 hours, then remove any leaves that are in bad shape. Thats it!

You can probably market that as an all-in-one fish disease cure as well. :LOL:
 
We have reached the end. 😥

This will be the final update and photo of my first aquascape. Over the last couple months, I've not given it the TLC it needs or deserves as I've been working on other projects, not just aquarium projects but general projects. This scape requires a considerable amount of time to maintain properly, and while the photo doesn't fully show it, my lack of attention is leading to poor health. The livestock and some plants such as the crypts and moss are still thriving, but other plants are struggling and algae is beginning to creep in. Also, the carpet of hairgrass is still being choked by moss and that may be one reason it never really reached it's potential after the last reset. Obviously, it's a bit overgrown in some areas but the fish don't mind that at all. In fact, the Platys love it. At one point I was down to having just 2 left in this tank and I thought both were females, but life finds a way. I started noticing a few small fry again but with the more dense plant mass, more survived this time and I now have quite a few.

The new 75g garden tank will be getting planted next weekend and I will then tear this one down a week or two later and move the livestock to the 75. The one dilemma will be what to do with the plants I don't have plans for in the garden, primarily all the crypts, anubias, and buce. For now I will keep the 40g farm tank going to just house those until I have a better place. I really don't want to get rid of them because I know I'll want them later.

So what is the future of this tank? Unkown 🤷‍♂️. I do know this though, it will be moving to the basement. In its place will be...drum roll...a new Waterbox Clear Mini 30. Yes, another new tank. Over the past few weeks, I've come to the realization that a number of the new and used tanks I purchased over the last year, are not really the footprints I'm really most interested in, so there's been a shift in my future scaping plans. The overall number of tanks I was planning to have in the house is going down, perhaps to single digits, as I get rid of some of the boxier footprint tanks. On the main floor of the house, the new 30 will be the largest volume tank. Everything else will be in the basement, where maintenance is easier.

They say you always remember your first. Remembering this scape won't be hard with all the photos, a journal, and an interview on Youtube to fondly look back on.


 
Back
Top