Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

Culturing Moina/Daphnia using Filtration

  • Thread starter Thread starter RickyV
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
Joined
Jul 23, 2023
Messages
201
Reaction score
526
Location
Texas
A few months ago I began experimenting with Moina to find a culture method that will eliminate crashes while being very little work to maintain. Culture crashes are typically caused from deteriorating water quality usually from overfeeding, but also from a population growing much larger than the culture can handle. This problem can easily be fixed with filtration. But we need the right type of filtration, something that will not remove the food and will not remove our Daphnia/Moina.

As long as we do not use mechanical filtration and only biological we will not significantly filter out the Daphnia/Moina food. I strongly recommend using a trickle/wet dry filter. Trickle filters will significantly boost biological filtration in a much smaller size, while providing massive aeration. Oxygen/aeration is going to be very important since our cultures will be very dense and produce a lot of waste.

As for keeping the Daphnia/Moina out of your filter simply cover your filter intake or pump in a 200 micron or less media bag (the bags used for carbon/GFO/purigen). Add a roll of canvas mesh or similar inside the bag to keep it from collapsing on to the filter intake. You will need to add snails to the culture to keep the mesh bag clean of debris. With snails there is no need to ever clean the bag.

I have also read papers that high nutrient concentrations (nitrates/phosphates) can negatively effect Daphnia populations. High nutrients signal to the Daphnia that there is little algae (food) in the water. For this I grow some emersed plants at the top of the trickle filter. The plants export a lot of nutrients, but as we all know plants don't remove everything so they don't completely remove the need for water changes. But I believe they significantly reduce the need. I have not done a large water change on my cultures yet, just removing small amounts here and there when I harvest and sometimes to water my plants.

Here is a picture of one of my setups as described above.
20250316_160812.jpg
You can see the media bag on the left corner which has my pump. The pump is one of the little 90 gph 5W pumps from Amazon. It goes up into the top tray which houses plants then below to a thick layer of aragonite as my biomedia. I chose aragonite for this filter since this culture uses RO water and the aragonite adds Ca/KH that is important for optimal production.

Here is another one of my setups.
20250226_083032.jpg

Feeding on these cultures is done using a typical fish auto feeder like this one.Screenshot_20250227_063858_Amazon Shopping.jpg

I fill it with yeast and set it to feed twice a day. Have the feeder dispense the yeast in an area of higher flow so it mixes well. The amount of yeast you feed is determined by how dense of a culture you want, it is something to experiment with and dial in to your needs. Right now my culture produces way more than I need and it is only 5 gallons. The beauty of this system is overfeeding is not as big of a concern as in traditional filterless cultures. Add an auto top off unit and this culture is almost completely automatic. An airlift tube on a timer can even be added to automatically harvest. Here is a video of my 5G culture, I think the density of my indoor culture rivals that of most outdoor cultures, but it can run year round and hands free.


I am now experimenting with a Daphnia culture that uses a blackworm powered infusoria reactor that I will share soon.
 
@RickyV, thank you so much for posting this. I'm debating whether it should be in the Articles section but will leave it here for now.

I think live food is something we don't often talk about in planted tanks. However, I have long wondered how I can keep a fully automated (read "easy") live food culture that I could then feed my tank from time to time.

Are you using the Daphnia for raising baby fish or do you feed this to adult fish?
 
@RickyV, thank you so much for posting this. I'm debating whether it should be in the Articles section but will leave it here for now.

I think live food is something we don't often talk about in planted tanks. However, I have long wondered how I can keep a fully automated (read "easy") live food culture that I could then feed my tank from time to time.

Are you using the Daphnia for raising baby fish or do you feed this to adult fish?
Yeah I was debating that as well, but I figured I'd add it here since this may continue to evolve. I agree! We spend so much effort into getting perfect beautiful plants but the fish should also look as good as the plants. Live foods really help with that. My fish are on a diet of 90% live foods. My fish have never looked as vibrant amd healthy as they are now. I feed the Daphnia to adult fish, and my Moina is better for raising baby fish. But the adults also love the Moina.
 
Based on the experiments you have done, what do you feel is a lower limit for a size, to stay hands-free, automated and stable? 2 gallons? 1 gallon? 🤔
This is something I've been meaning to do. A mini automatic moina culture. I have kept the Moina in 1L jars successfully without filtration/food (I used blackworm manure). They just don't get very dense in that. So I don't see why you couldn't keep them in something a small as 1 gallon automatic culture. This culture could even be an HOB breeding box. You can have the airlift on a timer to automatically feed your tank.
 
Btw, I’m going to set up a 10 gallon Moina tank this weekend, based on your setup. Thanks for all the info!
No problem! As I've had more time to experiment with this I will just say it does take some time balancing the right flow through your filter to the amount of food. Too much filtration will strip the Moina food too quickly. I'm working on figuring out more exact values.
 
What temperature do you keep them at? I’ve seen recommendations from 65-90, with the best being at 75. Do I need a heater if the room is usually around 70?
I keep them at whatever room temperature is. Right now it's been about 76-78. During winter it's been in the sixties. But now that I think about it my culture did much better in the winter, I can't confirm if it's for sure because of temperature but I'm starting to wonder if it is. My cultures recently have been having boom and bust cycles, where before they've had relatively stable dense populations. Ive heard Daphnia are very prone to boom and bust and Moina aren't, but im starting to wonder if it's the other way around. My daphnia populations can stay very stable even with little food supply. I have experimented with self sustaining Daphnia/Moina jars that have a layer of detritus, and only need topping off and dim light. The Moina boomed in these jars but busted eventually to a tiny population. The Daphnia in these have maintained their same decent population for a long time now. And I have had no input other than topping off.
 
I’m not sure whether to post this here, but it can be deleted if desired. I didn’t know what a trickle filter was, so I watched a couple of videos and made one.

I used food containers and tubing that I already had. I poked holes in the top two containers, and put an overflow in all 3 containers. The bottom container doesn’t have trickle holes so the media can be submerged. I cut out all but the edges of the lids for the bottom 2 containers, so they provide support but still allow the water to trickle through to the next level. Then I cut up the sponge filter that had been running in the tank and put the pieces in along with some other media that I had.

I had initially used silicone to attach the lids to the bottom of the trays and to go around the overflow tubes, but it didn’t stick to the plastic very well. It didn’t matter though, because the stack is wedged pretty well between the aquarium it’s being used for and the one above it. I just used a slightly larger tubing than the hole for the bottom tray, so it’s snug.

The first try didn’t work very well. I found I needed to put the pump on the lowest setting and cut the overflow tubes about 1/2 inch shorter. I also cut the foam into smaller pieces. Then it worked like a charm. Now I’m just waiting for the eggs to hatch.

IMG_7665.webp
IMG_7666.webp
 
@RickyV and @Kwyet - How are your setups progressing? Any new findings?
I’m afraid I gave up on it. I could hatch Moina and Daphnia, but they always died within a few days. I tried with and without a heater, with and without extra aeration, with eggs and with already hatched ones, and then gave it up.
 
@RickyV and @Kwyet - How are your setups progressing? Any new findings?
So a year experimenting with this I have learned this is not the ideal culture method for Moina. Moina in my experience boom and bust regardless of how good the water quality is or how much food is available to them. They seem to be best cultured using the batch method. But it is a very laborious method and it is why I think there are no commercial Moina products like there are things like frozen and freeze dried daphnia. Daphnia in my experience can have very dense and stable populations indefinitely given food and water quality are optimal. However I did find a relatively low effort method for culturing Moina, im just not sure if the Moina produced from it are of high enough quality. I'll share as soon as i get a chance

I found a different culture method for culturing daphnia, essentially what I have in this post but with a tray containing blackworms. The worms live in a sponge and I feed food on top of the sponge. The worms then generate huge amounts of waste/detritus/infusoria which acts as food for the daphnia. The daphnia for me in this method were very dense and stable with no direct feeding to them, only the worms. I even kept Moina in the tray containing the worms, and they lived there indefinitely but like I said their population density constantly varied.
Is the middle tray in your filter empty and used only for aeration?
Oh it was just a drip plate essentially for the biomedia below it.
I’m afraid I gave up on it. I could hatch Moina and Daphnia, but they always died within a few days. I tried with and without a heater, with and without extra aeration, with eggs and with already hatched ones, and then gave it up.
I have heard eggs are harder to start cultures from.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately I could mlt find picture of my productive low maintance Moina setups. But essentially what they were was 700ml - 1L plastic containers, they were filled with tank water a small clump of dero worms, maybe blackworms, and snails. I added the starter Moina and I feed the worms/snails a small piece of algae water. I would feed again once they finished it (ideally in 1-2 days) .After a few days the Moina were extremely dense for such a small container and the water was very cloudy. I could harvest daily and these would stay productive for many weeks, maybe longer without even water changing. But I guess I did techniqually do tiny water changes with every pipette full harvest.

This is an extremely easy, low effort culture method that needs little space. I have not concluded if the worms are nessecary but I feel they are beneficial, especially the dero worms as they are extremely tolerant of poor water quality. These can be done with just snails too. But the snails can't tolerate the poor water quality as well as the worms so it may not be as productive since tou wont be able to feed as heavily. But my snail cultures I remember still had decent populations of Moina. Now the downside of this method is I don't know if the Moina are high quality, or even safe to feed our fish since they're grown in small, stagnant, bacteria rich tubs of water. I have fed my fish some of these Mojna without problems, but I dont know if long term it may be different. But I could be wrong and they are completely safe and very nutritious. Im sure they would be as long as you didnt keep the cultures for more than a month before resetting.
 

Top 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top