Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

20+ year Reefkeeper turning to freshwater. Would like some feedback.

Looking to go a full planted Dutch style system

@Naturescapes_Rocco has done an end-to-end Journal on building out a similar tank, lots of good info in there 💯💯


End result:

1000055230.webp

👍👍
 
If going for more of a Dutch style, I think just having a flat substrate with perhaps just a bit of front to back slope may be better. In a Dutch scape arranging and trimming the plants to varying heights gives you that sense of contrast and having the substrate wavy/mounded may throw that off. Ultimately though, if it's just for your enjoyment and not competition, go with what is most pleasing to you.
Agreed on this.

Here's my upcoming 120cm dutch style scape:

1794690791642.webp

1794690797918.webp
 
Lighting: Are LED grow bulbs in the pendants enough for a high-tech 72" long, 24" deep tank, or is that a stopgap? If I upgrade, what would you put over it?
Here's my upcoming 120cm dutch style scape:

Oh and you will definitely want that Skylight Hyperspot 😁😁😁

 
Last edited:
Lighting: Are LED grow bulbs in the pendants enough for a high-tech 72" long, 24" deep tank, or is that a stopgap? If I upgrade, what would you put over it?

Here's my upcoming 120cm dutch style scape:

Oh and you will definitely want a Skylight Hyperspot 😁😁😁



Plenty of other light options out there that are less than the price of a used car, but then again it's not easy to sticker-shock a reefer 😅
 
Last edited:
Seriously, thank you, everyone. I went into this with an idea and completely changed it up for the better!

I am going to remove those mounds also and do a front to back slope.

I filled it with water today and set the sump up. What GPH flow does everyone aim for? I had standing waves with my reef, but I know it's minimal compared to that.

Don't laugh about my lighting. I pulled the halide reef bulbs and reused the pendants with these LED bulbs. I only chose them because they grew macroalgae like crazy in my reef refugium, so I figured it would grow plants. Will these work? What do you recommend for a 72x24x24 tank?

Screenshot_20261114_190040_Amazon Shopping.webp

Are there any good YouTube videos, etc., highlighting the Dutch style, as that is what I really want to focus on and try to imitate?
 
The go-to guide:

There are a lot of YouTube videos that call themselves “Dutch style”, but @Unexpected ’s series is the only one I know of that is truly Dutch. The others are Garden Style.


I use Week Aqua lights. Dennis Wong has a page on lights. I can’t really comment on the ones you have, although they may be fine.

 
As far as lights, it really comes down to how much you're willing to spend (I know your wife may have just sensed that comment 😁 ). Obviously, we go for different color spectrums and temperatures to enhance plant and fish colors in freshwater. While reef tanks might emphasize blue, freshwater emphasizes everything but blue. PAR levels depend a lot on the types of plants you're growing and growth rates you want. Slower growing plants like Anubias, Bucephalandra. crypts and other epiphytes, are best suited to low to moderate PAR levels while many stems and carpeting plants need high PAR. With that said, for a Dutch style scape, you'll probably want something in the medium to high range. Of course with newer app controlled LEDs, you can always turn them down. There are certain brands that have become very popular in aquascaping due to their wide range of adjustability. Fluval, Fzone, and a couple others on the low-mid range, Week Aqua, Chihiros, Twinstar, and Netlea on the mid-high price range, ADA and Skylight on the Upper-high range. While you can get by with common grow lights, you'll start to notice when comparing your tank to others you see in images or on Youtube, that you're colors just don't pop as much. I even found this to be the case with the first light I had on my first aquascape, the Fluval plant 3.0. Moving from it, to a Chihiros, made a huge difference in the look of my scape.. Of course then there's the decision between light bars, or pendants. Oh, so much to research and consider. Watching some youtube channels like Green Aqua and MJ Aquascaping and seeing what they use, can help. Also, here's a thread to give some ideas.

The Great Planted Aquarium Light Poll
 
What GPH flow does everyone aim for?

With plants it's much less about turnover, and more about flow 💯💯 you want to see that all of your plants in all areas of your tank move gently in the flow, so you know that nutrients and CO2 are getting to them.

Anything higher than that in a Dutch tank is not needed, but gets more complicated than you think as the plants get bigger 😅 In-tank surface skimmers or compact wavemakers can be used to improve dead spots when you have them.


Too much flow through your Yugang will also interfere with its functioning 👍 For this reason it's common to have the Yugang plumbed in on a bypass, so only part of your return flow is going through it and the rest goes past it.
 
The go-to guide:

There are a lot of YouTube videos that call themselves “Dutch style”, but @Unexpected ’s series is the only one I know of that is truly Dutch. The others are Garden Style.


I use Week Aqua lights. Dennis Wong has a page on lights. I can’t really comment on the ones you have, although they may be fine.


Thank you! Its beautiful. Watching @Unexpected is going to get me in trouble!! :-)
 
As far as lights, it really comes down to how much you're willing to spend (I know your wife may have just sensed that comment 😁 ). Obviously, we go for different color spectrums and temperatures to enhance plant and fish colors in freshwater. While reef tanks might emphasize blue, freshwater emphasizes everything but blue. PAR levels depend a lot on the types of plants you're growing and growth rates you want. Slower growing plants like Anubias, Bucephalandra. crypts and other epiphytes, are best suited to low to moderate PAR levels while many stems and carpeting plants need high PAR. With that said, for a Dutch style scape, you'll probably want something in the medium to high range. Of course with newer app controlled LEDs, you can always turn them down. There are certain brands that have become very popular in aquascaping due to their wide range of adjustability. Fluval, Fzone, and a couple others on the low-mid range, Week Aqua, Chihiros, Twinstar, and Netlea on the mid-high price range, ADA and Skylight on the Upper-high range. While you can get by with common grow lights, you'll start to notice when comparing your tank to others you see in images or on Youtube, that you're colors just don't pop as much. I even found this to be the case with the first light I had on my first aquascape, the Fluval plant 3.0. Moving from it, to a Chihiros, made a huge difference in the look of my scape.. Of course then there's the decision between light bars, or pendants. Oh, so much to research and consider. Watching some youtube channels like Green Aqua and MJ Aquascaping and seeing what they use, can help. Also, here's a thread to give some ideas.

The Great Planted Aquarium Light Poll

Perfect. Thanks for the info. I'll get some PAR readings of my lights to get a baseline of where they are at. I am sure I'll be upgrading very soon.
 
With plants it's much less about turnover, and more about flow 💯💯 you want to see that all of your plants in all areas of your tank move gently in the flow, so you know that nutrients and CO2 are getting to them.

Anything higher than that in a Dutch tank is not needed, but gets more complicated than you think as the plants get bigger 😅 In-tank surface skimmers or compact wavemakers can be used to improve dead spots when you have them.


Too much flow through your Yugang will also interfere with its functioning 👍 For this reason it's common to have the Yugang plumbed in on a bypass, so only part of your return flow is going through it and the rest goes past it.

Thank you. I'll be retiring the powerheads for now and look at some smaller powerheads down the road for deadspots.
 
I am looking to remove the four mesh bags of lava rocks. Could I do this while the tank is full, or do I need to drain the tank so as not to disturb the Eco-Complete and cause a silt storm?
Just remove and do a water change if it kicks up a mess. Otherwise, the sump will grab it.
 
Last edited:

Top 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top