My chat with ChatGPT on growing Rotala macrandra

  • Thread starter Thread starter Art
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Art

Administrator
Staff member
Founding Member
Journal
Joined
Oct 29, 2022
Messages
2,828
Reaction score
3,228
Location
Florida
I decided to test how well AI will do in recommending how to grow Rotala macrandra in a planted aquarium. Here is what it told me.

My question: How can I grow Rotala macrandra in a planted aquarium?

ChatGPT: To successfully grow Rotala macrandra in a planted aquarium, you need to provide the right conditions and care. Here are the steps you can follow:

1. Lighting: Rotala macrandra requires high-intensity lighting. Provide a good-quality aquarium light with a high output of around 3 to 4 watts per gallon (0.8 to 1 watt per liter). Use full-spectrum bulbs or LED lights that promote photosynthesis.

2. CO2 Injection: Rotala macrandra benefits from the addition of carbon dioxide (CO2) to the water. It encourages healthy growth and vibrant colors. Consider using a CO2 injection system or liquid carbon supplements to provide an adequate supply of CO2.

3. Substrate: Use a nutrient-rich substrate in your aquarium. Rotala macrandra appreciates a substrate that is rich in nutrients like iron, potassium, and other trace elements. You can use an aquarium soil or add root tabs for additional nutrients.

4. Water Parameters: Rotala macrandra prefers slightly acidic to neutral water conditions. Aim for a pH range of 6.0 to 7.5 and a temperature between 72°F to 82°F (22°C to 28°C). Provide good water circulation to prevent stagnation and maintain water quality.

5. Fertilization: In addition to the substrate, it is recommended to dose fertilizers regularly to provide essential nutrients to the plants. Look for a comprehensive aquarium fertilizer that includes macro and micronutrients. Follow the instructions on the product label for dosing guidelines.

6. Pruning and Maintenance: Rotala macrandra can grow quite tall and bushy. To maintain its shape and encourage compact growth, regularly trim the stems back. Use sharp, clean scissors or pruning tools to avoid damaging the plant. Remove any dead or decaying leaves to prevent them from affecting water quality.

7. Propagation: Rotala macrandra can be propagated through stem cuttings. When pruning the plant, cut healthy stems about 3 to 4 inches long and remove the bottom leaves. Plant the cuttings into the substrate, leaving sufficient space between each stem for light and airflow. They should develop roots and grow into new plants.

8. Patience and Experimentation: Growing Rotala macrandra can be a bit challenging, especially for beginners. It may take some time to find the right balance of lighting, fertilization, and CO2 supplementation for optimal growth. Be patient and willing to adjust these factors based on your plant's response.

Remember to monitor water parameters regularly, conduct water changes as needed, and keep an eye out for any signs of nutrient deficiencies or algae growth. With proper care and attention, you can enjoy the beautiful colors and lush growth of Rotala macrandra in your planted aquarium.

Well, not too bad, don't you think?
  • It used the VERY old watts per gallon to recommend light but it did mention high-intensity lighting.
  • It did recommend CO2 injection but implied liquid carbon supplements can add CO2.
  • Suggest adding fertilizer and having a good substrate.
  • Water parameters are wide enough to perhaps have good results.
  • Told to remove decaying leaves.
  • Encouraged patience and experimentation. Very good.
I give it a B- grade, I think.

I wonder how AI will play into our hobby in the near future?
 
I decided to test how well AI will do in recommending how to grow Rotala macrandra in a planted aquarium. Here is what it told me.

My question: How can I grow Rotala macrandra in a planted aquarium?



Well, not too bad, don't you think?
  • It used the VERY old watts per gallon to recommend light but it did mention high-intensity lighting.
  • It did recommend CO2 injection but implied liquid carbon supplements can add CO2.
  • Suggest adding fertilizer and having a good substrate.
  • Water parameters are wide enough to perhaps have good results.
  • Told to remove decaying leaves.
  • Encouraged patience and experimentation. Very good.
I give it a B- grade, I think.

I wonder how AI will play into our hobby in the near future?
Nice, cool idea! A little while back I used it to suggest alternatives for a plant in my tank that would still contrast with the other plants around it (which I told it too) and it also did okay. Very interested to see where it goes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Art
That's interesting @Art. Too biggest things generally are light and co2. Didn't mention PAR and using liquid carbon as alternative for co2 enrichment would be a deal breaker for me. Experienced users on forums like this still the best guide.
 
All Chat GPT does so far is aggrigate the web and consolidate the most (used, liked, top hits etc) things. It can not think for itself or suggest new ways to go about anything. So for example everyone watchs / flocks to and does everything DIY Joey and Aquarium COOP say it must be true right?
 
All Chat GPT does so far is aggrigate the web and consolidate the most (used, liked, top hits etc) things. It can not think for itself or suggest new ways to go about anything. So for example everyone watchs / flocks to and does everything DIY Joey and Aquarium COOP say it must be true right?
My thoughts as well. It looks like it summarized a bunch of information commonly found on the web. Whether half of it is true or not makes no difference. The more often it's cited somewhere, the more likely it is to be included.

I bet it says iron turns plants red too! ;)
 
Well, I'm grateful it can't think for itself. It's like with school - at some point, regurgitating what you memorized isn't going to cut it. You need to learn and apply. That's what we do.

That being said, though. For new people to the hobby that don't have the ability or time to spend sifting through the Internet for "what to do", AI summarizing it for them is going to be a good start. Yes, what it came up with above isn't totally correct but it will certainly give someone a head start.
 
Back
Top