Black roots - what to do ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter anewbie
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

anewbie

Community Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2023
Messages
88
Reaction score
60
Location
USA
I was transplanting one of my E. Opacus and noticed some of the roots black. They were not rotten or mushy but rather hard like wire. Unsure if i should have trimmed them or left them (for now i left them); I presume (perhaps incorrectly) this is due to anaerobic activity in the other aquarium but unclear if this is bad for the plant or i should remove them if they are not rotten.
 
Hi - without a picture, it's hard to tell. IME, roots should be healthy and usually on the white/light tan side. Black usually means they are necrotic and dead.

My best suggestion is to watch them. If they begin to rot, cut them.
 
My best suggestion is to watch them. If they begin to rot, cut them.
While not bad advice it is not one easily executed as one has to dig the plant up (or at least the roots) to 'watch' them. As it turns out i will be moving in 6 to 10 weeks and at that point i will check it again (and take pictures). The plant is not one that loves to be disturb and my intention was to move this aquarium (a 10) by removing the water and then setting it on a board to carry it to the car and into eventually into the new residence but digging around the plant will still be feasible. I'll have to leave a little water in the aquarium given the large number of shrimps and similar that will want to resist being moved.
 
I realize the roots will be buried, unless it was an epiphyte, but there is no other way. You either cut them now or check every so often by pulling it up.

I'm a believer in if it ain't broke, don't fix it. If your plant is growing well, then don't worry about the roots.
 
Back
Top