Welcome to ScapeCrunch

We are ScapeCrunch, the place where planted aquarium hobbyists come to build relationships and support each other. When you're tired of doom scrolling, you've found your home here.

An alternative approach to CO2?

Wow 😁😁

Do you have the ability to incorporate an oxygen sensor as well, for livestock? 🤔
Good thinking (y) yeah, I have the ability and already used two of them in prior projects. But they both been broken (one on my own fault as I dropped it on the floor, the other one stopped reporting valid values after 6 weeks) and the module cost around 60-90 euros. So I won't go there anytime soon. The reasoning is:

Assume the hood is 100% airtight. Air exists of 78% Nitrogen, 21% oxygen and 0.043% (430ppm) and the rest is primarily Argon. When you would add CO2 up to the debatable 15-30 ppm in water (I would go for 10% but hey...), you would need to increase CO2 in the hood by 1-2% (10k-20k ppm). So it doesn't push out any relevant volume of oxygen from the hood (2% times 21%, so oxygen would reduce to 20.5% ). Increasing CO₂ from 430 ppm to 10,000–20,000 ppm only reduces the initial oxygen fraction slightly, assuming the added CO₂ displaces an equivalent volume of air. That displacement alone is not a meaningful oxygen risk.

During photosynthesis CO2 gets converted to oxygen, hence the pearling and increased oxygen saturation. At night it's different, and plants are oxygen consumers and CO2 producers. My tank has an (in-hood) air pump 24/7 to increase diffusion. So any oxygen available in the hood gets transported into the water, trying to get oxygen to 100% (8.3 ppm) and CO2 to 15-30ppm. The volume of CO2 might likely increase greater than the 1-2%. At this point the ventilation disc is opened and fresh air gets into the hood. CO2 volume will be forced down to 10k - 20k ppm. However, I realize that aeration can only transfer oxygen that's actually available in the hood.

So if we are adding relatively low amount of CO2 compared to oxygen in the hood, how can the volume of oxygen in the water drop below a critical threshold? If diffusion rate is low, it makes no sense to monitor oxygen in the water as oxygen in air can be good, but be low in the water. On the other hand If diffusion is good, why should I worry about oxygen, as the system would have enough oxygen to begin with.

The only situation where oxygen monitoring would make sense, when the entire system looses oxygen and no fresh air/oxygen intake would take place. But it does, the hood isn't 100% airtight and gets fresh air at night. Or another situation: when the CO2 sensor fails to measure the correct value, and CO2 is much higher. But then measuring oxygen is no an issue anymore, livestock would be gassed by CO2 already.

So by this reasoning I won't purchase an oxygen sensor soon, but I'll test the tank with just plants and small invertabrates. If all is well after a few months, some fish can be introduced. If the tank crashes or stays unhealthy, I always can get an oxygen sensor to eliminate it as possible cause. Or even better, shut down possible CO2 input and fully open the ventilation disc, so it is a regular CO2 injected tank. And aerating the tank by an external air pump is always possible.

But I agree, all reasoning can be eliminated by an oxygen sensor to begin with, but I didn't have any luck as it broke down.

Cheers!
 
Thank you again, and I believe you pioneer what could emerge as a new CO2 technology over time. It will take time, as we see with the horizontal reactor, but there is no way of stopping concepts that have undeniable benefits. It may take 3-5 years, but you're the first to prove the concept.
I think the solution is still technology dependant and that's okay even interesting from a personal point of view. But in the end the best systems are less dependant on technology. "Keep It Simple". I assume experience hobbyist in high tech tanking know why. I think the horizontal reactor is a good example of keeping it simple. I believe the concept of this alternative approach can deliver stable CO2 as well, and reduce the amount of CO2 used as CO2 can't escape easily by the airtight hood.

We will see in the future how the concept turns out.

If you go for bottled CO2, then I guess the proof of concept would be to inject a steady 0.5 or 1% CO2 in the headspace, stabilise that and run your tank for a couple of months.

I'll buy myself a 500 gr bottle and a new regulator as my old dual stage Vulkan F10/2 need a revision which would get expensive. But yes, It would need to run several months and report back what the results are.
 
But in the end the best systems are less dependant on technology. "Keep It Simple".
I agree. My long-term vision for this solution is commercially integrated tanks where CO2 levels can be easily set remotely without any need for knowledge of needle valve management, CO2 measurement or dialling in.

While I don’t expect everyone to favour this approach, I believe the simplicity of setting a specific CO2 level via a phone app offers significant advantages.
 
I agree. My long-term vision for this solution is commercially integrated tanks where CO2 levels can be easily set remotely without any need for knowledge of needle valve management, CO2 measurement or dialling in.

While I don’t expect everyone to favour this approach, I believe the simplicity of setting a specific CO2 level via a phone app offers significant advantages
Yes, setting a CO2 level and the system take care of the rest... I guess there would be a market for it.


When you advocate for the concept, you are signing yourself up for installing and using such a device for the sake of the community and your karma. You know do you? ;)
 
When you advocate for the concept, you are signing yourself up for installing and using such a device for the sake of the community and your karma. You know do you? ;)
Frankly, I’ve been incredibly busy with some responsibilities for the past two years and it seems I’ll need to commit for another two. While I do maintain my tank, I simply don’t have the time to actively explore test or engage on the forum. I recently upgraded my tank but opted for the quickest route with a reactor I fully understand and know works.

If the technology were available I’d definitely install it. I love the idea of setting my CO2 levels on a phone app and forgetting about it. My interest in CO2 methods began because I was frustrated by how many hobbyists were struggling. We all want to grow plants and keep fish, not struggle with CO2.
 
This project needs an update. Behold my prototype CO2 controller on an actual tank:
View attachment 21186
You can see the airtight hood:
  • The red module in front of the hood is the CO2 sensor (SCD41) reading the CO2 in the trapped air in the lid.
  • CO2 is injected via bio CO2.
  • When CO2 increases the ventilation valve/disc with the motor attached (in the right back corner) controls the amount of degassing of CO2.
  • left from the sensor is a wire to a fan which is installed under the lid, mixing the air and speeding up the response time sensing any CO2 change.
  • The black thing standing in the tank is an airlift and a small piezzo-electric airpump is installed in the hood as well, maximizing the diffusion rate.
  • (and an optional temperature sensor is installed.)
The whole setup isn't super simple but not very complicated as well.

Still needs cleaning up the wiring, making it a bit more compact and printing a (water tight) cover for it.
And still need to hook up the received RGB led and speaker so in case of an emergency break some local alerting can be implemented.

It works like a charm, but with using bio CO2 the production can peak, so it needs a bigger ventilation opening and disc.
The test tank was aerated before the makeover, so plant growth is way better now at 5-7 ppm instead of 1-1.5. Go figure!

I might go for bottled CO2 for more input stability and the sake of testing the controller at higher ppms.

A question for you all. Are you still interested in this stuff? Anything you are particularly interested in?
This is very very cool!

My biggest interest is mostly how you find it impacts, or doesn’t impact, you interacting with the tank for maintenance etc.
what is the lag time after opening the hood to trim or pick something out of the tank? How does it cope with being disturbed, and what is the ramp up like for it finding an equilibrium again?
 
My biggest interest is mostly how you find it impacts, or doesn’t impact, you interacting with the tank for maintenance etc.
what is the lag time after opening the hood to trim or pick something out of the tank? How does it cope with being disturbed, and what is the ramp up like for it finding an equilibrium again?
When the tank lid is opened, CO2 enriched air will escape from the headspace. Water CO2 ppm will hardly be impacted by a short opening.
Close the lid, and the typical time it takes is to enrich the headspace upto less than 1% CO2. So it seems not much of a problem, nor a big CO2 loss.
 
Frankly, I’ve been incredibly busy with some responsibilities for the past two years and it seems I’ll need to commit for another two. While I do maintain my tank, I simply don’t have the time to actively explore test or engage on the forum. I recently upgraded my tank but opted for the quickest route with a reactor I fully understand and know works.

If the technology were available I’d definitely install it. I love the idea of setting my CO2 levels on a phone app and forgetting about it. My interest in CO2 methods began because I was frustrated by how many hobbyists were struggling. We all want to grow plants and keep fish, not struggle with CO2.
Ah, no worries, just teasing. You can get your hand dirty when motivation and time are available. For now I appreciate your response over here (y) 🙏
 
My biggest interest is mostly how you find it impacts, or doesn’t impact, you interacting with the tank for maintenance etc.
Well, for now the test tank is on the ground. That impact interaction with the tank the most... I'm used to closed lid tanks and never owned an open top. Opening up the tank is somewhat harder right now with the electronics built on and under the hood, but it remains very light weight. A new prototype would be engineered to take in account easy access.
 
what is the lag time after opening the hood to trim or pick something out of the tank? How does it cope with being disturbed, and what is the ramp up like for it finding an equilibrium again?
Currently the ventilation disc is closed 24/7 and the target level is being met for 90%. So CO2 input is low. I consider the lag time 75-90 minutes after opening the hood:
1793290797968.webp
When CO2 input would be enough to meet the target, lag time would be shorter.

When the tank lid is opened, CO2 enriched air will escape from the headspace. Water CO2 ppm will hardly be impacted by a short opening.
Close the lid, and the typical time it takes is to enrich the headspace upto less than 1% CO2. So it seems not much of a problem, nor a big CO2 loss.
I think Yugang is right: CO2 level in the water should be much affected. But for much bigger hoods this might be different. This is one of the reason I developed my digital drop checker (as I thew my DYI pH monitor in the recycle bin.) So I can actually measure what the CO2 level is during these events. Not yet installed though.

To be continued...
 
When CO2 input would be enough to meet the target, lag time would be shorter
When using bottled CO2, with more CO2 injection capacity, this seems an almost trivial optimisation problem to solve.

When injecting CO2 in the headspace, do it with a "puff" from the solenoid rather than slow "bubble by bubble" as in traditional injection with needle valve adjustments. Wait perhaps a minute after a "puff", and measure CO2 concentration in the enriched air in the headspace. If needed, give it another puff, or maybe more. Repeat until target CO2 concentration (typically 0.5-1%) in headspace reached.

We could do some calculations, and model to optimise the process, but to me it seems the system could get to its target CO2 in the headspace within a few minutes, if not shorter. The tank water CO2 will have almost no impact during this adjustment and be almost perfectly stable.

Note: When we understand the system better, and have modelled it, perhaps we don't use "puffs" anymore, but a more continuous approach with a needle valve at a much higher flow rate than we traditionally use.
 
Last edited:
Still, very impressive work
It’s fantastic that @PeerUnk does this work; it’ll be a valuable resource for the planted tank community.


I’d like to express some personal frustration with the commercial partners in this hobby.

I posted this idea now nearly three years ago. My confidence as a physicist that this will work and has no major problems is perhaps 80-90%.

If we can control CO2 via a phone app, why would anyone bother with a needle valve on a pricey CO2 regulator while monitoring a pH probe for the right setting?

As an experienced hobbyist, I’d say it’s highly likely that in a decade, this CO2 technology will become one of the most popular, perhaps even the most popular, for the planted tank hobby. It’s convenient, does not require expertise, and can be more affordable than todays solutions.

It’s a shame that commercial “partners” in the hobby often overlook innovative ideas from experienced hobbyists. They don’t lead the development of these ideas into new products that benefit the community. Instead they wait for a free solution to be offered and then commercialise it when they’re ready. In my humble opinion, sorry to say, this isn’t a valued service to the hobby and certainly not a partnership.
 
It’s fantastic that @PeerUnk does this work; it’ll be a valuable resource for the planted tank community.


I’d like to express some personal frustration with the commercial partners in this hobby.

I posted this idea now nearly three years ago. My confidence as a physicist that this will work and has no major problems is perhaps 80-90%.

If we can control CO2 via a phone app, why would anyone bother with a needle valve on a pricey CO2 regulator while monitoring a pH probe for the right setting?

As an experienced hobbyist, I’d say it’s highly likely that in a decade, this CO2 technology will become one of the most popular, perhaps even the most popular, for the planted tank hobby. It’s convenient, does not require expertise, and can be more affordable than todays solutions.

It’s a shame that commercial “partners” in the hobby often overlook innovative ideas from experienced hobbyists. They don’t lead the development of these ideas into new products that benefit the community. Instead they wait for a free solution to be offered and then commercialise it when they’re ready. In my humble opinion, sorry to say, this isn’t a valued service to the hobby and certainly not a partnership.
We still only have one relatively small business producing your horizontal reactors, even though there's now plenty of info out there regarding it's performance and value. I'm sure ARC doesn't mind being the sole manufacturer, but competition is good for consumers. I would like to see ARC or someone else produce a smaller version of the adjustable acrylic reactor for sub 90cm tanks. Then again, this is one of those hobbies people do enjoy DIY projects. We just don't always have the time, just as you have mentioned.
 
We still only have one relatively small business producing your horizontal reactors, even though there's now plenty of info out there regarding it's performance and value. I'm sure ARC doesn't mind being the sole manufacturer, but competition is good for consumers. I would like to see ARC or someone else produce a smaller version of the adjustable acrylic reactor for sub 90cm tanks. Then again, this is one of those hobbies people do enjoy DIY projects. We just don't always have the time, just as you have mentioned
I posted that I can build a reactor for a 50 gallon tank for less than 10 USD, and I could build 4 of them in one hour. One could argue that is not helping the commercial viability.

However, for the device @PeerUnk is pioneering, DIY integration won’t be straightforward. However, it could be integrated into tanks by leading manufacturers, much like they include their branded lighting solutions. This presents a very appealing commercial opportunity.
 
Currently the ventilation disc is closed 24/7 and the target level is being met for 90%. So CO2 input is low. I consider the lag time 75-90 minutes after opening the hood:
View attachment 21227
When CO2 input would be enough to meet the target, lag time would be shorter.


I think Yugang is right: CO2 level in the water should be much affected. But for much bigger hoods this might be different. This is one of the reason I developed my digital drop checker (as I thew my DYI pH monitor in the recycle bin.) So I can actually measure what the CO2 level is during these events. Not yet installed though.

To be continued...
That’s still pretty good with your current setup.
a change to pressurised CO2 could take that down to almost nothing, although it would waste a lot of CO2 with constant open/close of the hood. A simple feeding/maintenance switch/timer button fixes that though.
 
Just out of curiosity, what would happen to the plants if you just turned co2 up to max in this system?
At what ppm point does the entire system fail and the plants suffer from intoxication, if thats even possible.


Do the growth forms of plants get really wonky at 200ppm of co2 or something? That might be something only consistently possible in this system since you can control degassing so well.
 
I don't think plants would fail because of too much CO2 itself, remember that 90% of the plants in our hobby also live terrestrially in CO2 concentrations around 400ppm.

In aquaria, the bigger issue would probably be from the extreme acidification of the water. I'm sure there are some plants that really wouldn't thrive at 4.5pH, though there are plenty of rivers in the world near that pH that have healthy plant life...

Point is, I'm really not sure there's a direct issue with injecting too much CO2 in terms of plants, but asphyxiating fish/shrimp/snails is definitely a thing.
 

Top 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top